Anti-capitalism as the new Antisemitism? Alain Soral faces two years in prison for criticizing Capitalists


The French essayist Alain Soral was sentenced on September 19 to 18 months imprisonment for having broadcast an antisemitic rap song in which portraits of personalities were burned online.

PARIS – Alain Bonnet better known as Alain Soral, was convicted on antisemitism charges under France’s laws, in an incident in which he rhetorically attacked well known capitalists. Critics of France’s laws characterize these as overly broad and punitive, and perhaps as much responsible for growing antisemitism inasmuch as they appear to validate the wildest conspiracy theories of antisemites themselves. 

Soral will be forced to pay a fine of 45,000 euros (or 50k USD).
Formally, he was prosecuted for provoking racial hatred and aggravated public insult. 


The Criminal Court of Bobigny sentenced the writer to two years imprisonment including six months suspended with probation for a period of three years. The sentence consists of three measures: 210 hours of community service, either for a full-time one and a half months of hard labor, removal of the incriminated publication under penalty of 1,000 euros per day of delay and compensation for “victims”.

In a statement published on September 19, Alain Soral’s lawyer, Damien Viguier, detailed the terms of the conviction.

The total could exceed the 171,000 euros: 45 000 euros fine, publication of the judgment in the newspaper Le Monde for 15 days (estimating at 4,000 euros each publication, because the price of the character, spaces included, is astronomical) and 10,000 euros to each civil party whose legal fees will be covered by Soral to up to 1,000 euros (there were six civil parties, including Licra, Uejf, SOS Racism, J’accuse, Mrap and Ldh).


What was the actual nature of the acts considered criminal by the French authorities?

It would appear that the writer is condemned only because as founder and president of the association Equality & Reconciliation he is held to be the director of the publication of the site responsible for the offending publications.

In question was about a rap song called Yellow Vests in which nothing appeared to be objectionable at first said his lawyer. But the associations that had launched the lawsuits against Soral claimed to have “decoded the words and images”.

Published on Soral’s website Equality and Reconciliation, the video in which a sign containing the name of Rothschild was thrown at traffic light, was shown.

A fire at a roundabout manned by Yellow Vests became “a pyre” and the word “parasite” was translated as the “will to total extermination” when photos of Rothshild, Jacques Attali, Patrick Drahi and Bernard Henri Levi were thrown into the fire.

Thus fifteen seconds of images on a clip of four minutes and thirty-two seconds convinced the magistrates of Bobigny of its profoundly antisemitic nature.

On April 15th, the essayist, who had already been condemned many times, was sentenced to one year for failing to appear in another case. The Paris Criminal Court then ordered an arrest warrant against him, which the prosecution had refused to execute, considering that it had no legal basis.

On June 5th in Paris, a year in prison was handed to him him for having qualified the Pantheon as “kosher waste” in a video posted in July 2018 on his website.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Sign up here to get the latest news, updates and special offers delivered directly to your inbox.
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x